Why did Etsy sell Reverb and Depop?
Etsy sold both to focus on the core marketplace. Its 10-Q says the Depop sale was made to concentrate on driving growth in the Etsy marketplace, and the same wording appears for Reverb. Reverb, the musical instrument marketplace, was sold on June 2, 2025 for $105 million in cash, subject to adjustments. Depop was sold to eBay on July 30, 2026 for $1.4 billion, made up of a $1.2 billion price plus about $200 million of net adjustments and interest, producing an $839.7 million gain.
The Depop numbers show why. Through the sale date in 2026, Depop's reported revenue was $138.6 million, while its marketing expense was $293.9 million, more than double its revenue. Depop's operating loss in that period was $294.7 million. Depop was absorbing heavy marketing spend relative to its revenue, and selling it left Etsy with a single marketplace to run. Etsy also repurchased about $0.8 billion of its own stock in the first nine months of 2026.
For marketplace builders the lesson is about focus. A portfolio of niche marketplaces (instruments, fashion, handmade) can share technology but not necessarily economics. Shipturtle's roundup of multi-vendor marketplace examples built on Shopify shows how single-niche marketplaces focus their own supply and audience.
What can a marketplace builder borrow from Etsy's fee stack?
Four things. First, no single fee has to carry the model. Etsy's standard stack is a modest 10% on a sale, and the rest of its take rate comes from optional layers sellers choose into. Second, tie the fee to an outcome where you can. Etsy charges the Offsite Ads fee only on a sale, which is easy for sellers to accept. Third, keep a small fixed fee on listings, because it works as a quality filter on inventory as well as revenue. Fourth, change the base rate rarely: Etsy's transaction fee went from 5% to 6.5% in April 2022 and has stayed at 6.5% since, with take rate growth coming from optional layers instead.
Shipturtle is a Shopify-native multi-vendor marketplace platform that handles vendor onboarding, order splitting, commissions and payouts. Commission automation sets the base rate per vendor or per category, which is the foundation layer of a stack like Etsy's. Shipturtle connects to the shipping providers a marketplace already uses, supports several shipping accounts on one platform, and payout integrations pay vendors through Stripe and PayPal. If your plan is an Etsy-style marketplace for creators, the Etsy clone page and the guide to creating a marketplace like Etsy walk through that setup, and the customers page shows live marketplaces built this way. Marketplace setup typically takes one to two weeks at most.
The practical approach is to start with commission and add one layer at a time, measuring each before the next, instead of launching a full stack on day one. Etsy took years to build the layers described above.